Let’s design to the edges for every learner.

Beth Stark, home

Activity

Barrier or Important Factor?

An interactive card sort

The Barrier Is in the Design, Not in the Learner

When we notice something getting in the way of learning, it helps to know the difference between a barrier in the design and an important factor.

The card sort starts from one tenet of UDL: barriers live in designs, not in students (The IRIS Center, 2023). Use it to practise telling the two apart.

Barrier in the design

Something in our design or environment we can choose to reduce.

  • Never in the learner.
  • Always in the design.
  • We can reduce them.

Important factor

A real condition of the learner, the family or the wider context. Often beyond our direct control.

  • Valued parts of identity and context.
  • We do not design them away.
  • We design for them.

A note on variability: Many, but not all, important factors are aspects of learner variability we can anticipate and embrace in our design process. Variability is the rule, not the exception.

Try the Card Sort

This activity is played on screen. Open it at bethstark.org/udl-resources/barrier-sort.html.

The card sort needs JavaScript. You can still read all 30 cards, sorted, below.

See all 30 cards, sorted

Barriers in the design (15)

  • Success criteria are missing, or they are written in language that is too ambiguous or complex for learners to understand.Success criteria become a meaningful part of the design when they are shared or co-constructed with learners throughout the learning experience.
  • The most meaningful, actionable feedback is offered only with or after the summative assessment.The timing of feedback is part of the design. Feedback during the learning gives learners time to use it.
  • Check-ins about learning progress and depth of understanding allow learners only one way to respond.The ways learners can respond are part of the design. Options to show, express and share what they are learning reduce this barrier.
  • Taking part in class discussions means one thing for learners: giving quick answers out loud.What counts as taking part is part of the design. More time to prepare responses, or the option to offer them in another format, reduces this barrier.
  • A big task is shared all at once, and the smaller steps are missing or too unclear for learners to use to plan their own timeline.The structure of a task is part of the design. Clear chunks and checkpoints give learners a map and a timeline to make their own.
  • Learning engagements have no built-in reflection time for learners to think back on their learning.The use of time is part of the design. Built-in reflection time reduces this barrier.
  • A learning engagement requires background knowledge and skills that many learners may not have yet. Tricky.What learners already know and can do is an important factor. The barrier is the learning engagement that depends on it. We can activate or share that knowledge first.
  • Rigid in-class time limits are set for learning tasks, even when speed is not part of the goal.A time limit is part of the design. When speed is not part of the goal, flexible timing reduces this barrier.
  • New vocabulary and concepts appear with no time or support to make meaning from them first.The timing of new vocabulary and concepts is part of the design. Intentionally designed scaffolds for introducing them reduce this barrier.
  • Group work has no clear roles or timing.The structure of group work is part of the design. Clear roles and timings reduce this barrier.
  • Instructions are only spoken, with nothing written or pictured to look back at.The format of instructions is part of the design. Written or pictured steps give learners something to return to.
  • Feedback is given only orally or in handwritten comments, including for learners who are acquiring the language of instruction as an additional language. Tricky.Acquiring an additional language is an important factor. The barrier is feedback in a format that learners cannot return to or make meaning from. Options might include typed comments or a recording to replay.
  • A training session uses unfamiliar tools and unexplained acronyms, with no scaffolds or options for support.What each learner already knows is an important factor. The barrier is a session with no scaffolds for using the tools or for making meaning of the acronyms. Options might include a short guide to the tools and a list of the acronyms.
  • During deep learning time, there is a lot of conversation and movement, and learners who need quiet to think or read have no options. Tricky.Some learners need quiet to think or read. That is learner variability, an important factor. The barrier is the lack of options. Options might include a quieter space or headphones.
  • A class has 5 tablets for 30 learners, and the task is planned without groups or rotations. Tricky.The amount of resources in a classroom changes, and it is always an important factor. The barrier is a task planned without groups or rotations. How we plan around the resources is part of the design.

Important factors (15)

  • Many learners in a group speak more than one language at home.This describes the learners in the group. We can plan for it, for example with key vocabulary in more than one language.
  • Learners in a group work at different speeds, and some need more time to take in information.This is learner variability. We can anticipate it and plan for it, for example with flexible timing.
  • Some learners prefer to join in by writing, and others by speaking.This is learner variability. We can plan for it with more than one way to take part.
  • Some learners have painful memories of earlier school that can affect how they approach new work.This is part of what some learners bring to school, and it is beyond our control. We can anticipate it and design learning experiences and environments that optimise emotional safety.
  • Attention and energy drop in the early afternoon, straight after lunch.This is a condition of the school day. We can plan for it, for example with movement or a change of activity.
  • On Monday mornings, many learners are still getting into the week.This is a condition of the school week. We can plan for it in how Monday lessons begin.
  • In the last period of the day, many learners are tired and ready to go home.This is a condition of the timetable. We can plan for it by designing learning experiences that fit that time of day.
  • Many adult learners fit study around work and family, and are not available for group projects outside class. Tricky.Work and family commitments are an important factor. A barrier in the design would be a course that requires group projects outside class, with no other option.
  • Some adults come back to study after years away, and bring personal and professional expertise with them.Time away from study and the expertise adults bring are important factors. A barrier in the design would be content and materials with no link to their lives, and no invitation to share and draw on that expertise.
  • Some learners provide child care for younger siblings, which leaves almost no time for studying and homework/home learning. Tricky.Caring for younger siblings is an important factor, beyond our control. A barrier in the design would be homework/home learning with one way and one time to complete it.
  • The school has few devices and limited resources for materials. Tricky.Limited resources are an important factor. A barrier in the design would be a task that requires a device for each learner, in place of rotations, stations and group work that widen access to the devices available.
  • A class has 13 microscopes for 18 learners, and each lab is planned around them. Tricky.The number of microscopes is an important factor, and the lab is planned around it. A barrier in the design would be a lab that requires one microscope for each learner, with no other option.
  • The room is shared, and tables and equipment are moved between lessons.A shared room is a condition of the setting. We can plan for it, for example with a set-up routine.
  • Learners arrive from different schools, each with its own routines.Earlier school experience is an important factor. We can plan for it by teaching the routines of the new school.
  • Parents and caregivers work shifts, so evening events may be hard to attend.Shift work is an important factor. A barrier in the design would be events held only in the evening.

Barriers and important factors vary with context. These cards are examples.

Keep Going

References

The IRIS Center. (2023). Page 2: Addressing barriers. In Universal Design for Learning: Designing learning experiences that engage and challenge all students. Peabody College, Vanderbilt University. https://iris.peabody.vanderbilt.edu/module/udl/cresource/q1/p02/

By Beth Stark. Licensed under CC BY-NC 4.0.

Accessibility and Settings

Listen to this page
Font
Text size
Line spacing
Letter and word spacing
Colours
Motion